Haverstick's post

Incidentally, I recall an almost identical post by Neil about a year ago.
Maybe it was exactly identical. Neil?

But I don't understand your point here, Daniel.

>"you don't need to use infinitely high factors to get an infinite JI set of
>pitches" (trivial but true)

What's the difference between this and Paul's actual statement? You've
swapped "harmonic series" for "factors"? Either way, it is true, as you
point out. Hardly "nonsense".

>"JI systems can use a small set of simple intervals locally, generating a
>potentially infinite set of pitches globally" (which starts to suggest how
>this works in real musics).

Of course, you can make plenty of music from a single harmonic series.
Making 1- or 2-D chains of simple generators is popular, but hardly the
only path to "real musics".

-Carl