back to list

Henry Ward Poole

🔗threesixesinarow <CACCOLA@NET1PLUS.COM>

11/18/2005 12:39:23 PM

Contributors Club. The Atlantic Monthly Vol. LXVII, January 1891. p136

One of the Lost Geniuses

The telegraph announces the death in the city of Mexico, October 21st,
of Henry Ward Poole, one of the oldest American residents of that
city. It speaks of him as a man of rare attainments, and as having
received the degree of M. A. from Harvard College. Mr. Poole was so
unique a personality and so much of a public character that some
reminiscence of him may possess interest. I believe he was a native of
Danvers, Mass., but for some years the family resided near Worcester.
I first knew him at Yale College in 1842, where he was a member of the
class of 1815. His brother was a classmate of mine, and became a
somewhat intimate friend, and the two roomed together. I do not
remember that I made much progress in Henry's acquaintance at that
time, although I saw him frequently. He appeared to me to be always
intensely busy about something, and had a preoccupied air.
At the beginning of his junior year he did not return, and as his
brother was also absent for a while I lost track of him. I next met
him at Worcester, at a house where I was visiting, and where he had
called to borrow a volume of the Encyclopedia Britannica. I found that
he wanted to consult the article on Music, and especially the
mathematical portion, and that in regard to everything relating to the
theory of music he was well informed. He told me that he was studying
the subject of organs, and invited me to come and see him at his home,
two or three miles from the city. I afterwards made the visit, and on
this occasion I referred to our acquaintance in college, and asked him
why he left.
"Oh," he replied, "I was there for a temporary purpose only, and
having accomplished that I left"
"Well ?" said I interrogatively, intimating that I should like to know
more.
"Yes," said he, "I will tell you all about it, if you care to listen.
The fact, is I have a taste, or I might say a natural aptitude, for
mechanics, aiid I thought I should like to do something in a
mechanical way which was worth doing. I investigated a good many
mechanical pursuits, and I came to the conclusion that organ building
was about the most difficult, and therefore the best worth doing, of
any.
"Now, you see, to build an organ it is necessary to know a good many
things. First of all a man should thoroughly understand the theory of
music, and to do that requires a considerable knowledge of
mathematics. It was that which took me to college. I didn't care
anything about Latin and Greek and other things, but I did want
mathematics, and I decided that I could get them in college better
than elsewhere ; so I fitted for college. Of course I had to study
Latin and Greek and other things, but I got the mathematics that I
wanted, and although it took a good deal of time, on the whole, I am
not sorry. Well, when I had the mathematics, that was all I cared for,
and then I left.
"Now, in organ building a good deal of leather is used, and it is
necessary to understand something about the tanning and
preparation and finish of several different kinds of leather ; so I
apprenticed myself to a tanner, until I could do a respectable job in
tanning and finishing piano leather.
"Also there are the metal pipes. In order to understand them one must
be familiar with certain kinds of metal work well, I learned that, and
then filing, turning, forging, and finishing steel and iron, — in
short, the ordinary work of a machinist. I did enough at that to be a
respectable workman.
"Next, there is the ivory work that is a department by itself, and had
to be learned; but I had done so many similar things that I found it
quite easy. The cabinet work and the other wood work was more of a
task ; for it is not only necessary to know all about working woods,
but one must also know a great deal about the different kinds of wood,
— their peculiarities and possibilities. There is more wood about an
organ than anything else, and everything depends on the kind, quality,
condition, and workmanship of this wood. It took me a long time to
master this, although I did not find the mechanical part difficult.
There is some of my work. I made everything in that, and he pointed to
a highly finished parlor organ which I had already remarked on account
of its beauty."
"You made that?" I said, doubtless indicating some surprise.
"Certainly," said he; "why not? I ought to do as good work as another
man after having learned the trade. Well," he continued, "to make a
rather long story short, I have mastered, I think, what there is to be
known in this country about organs. Now I am going abroad to see if
they have anything to teach me there, and in twenty-five years from
the time I began I expect to be able to make as good an organ as has
ever been produced."
The coolness with which he laid out half of an ordinary business life
to the purpose of acquiring an art almost took away my breath ; but I
found that he was perfectly serious. No commercial view seemed to
present itself in the matter. His one thought was that he should
himself be able to build a perfect organ.
Four or five years later, in 1850, Poole produced his Enharmonic
Organ, which for a time attracted much attention in musical circles.
His own account of it appeared in Silliman's Journal of Science ; and
there were several articles in other magazines, and numerous notices
in the papers of the time. As nearly as I can recollect, this
invention was an attempt to give every scale perfectly, by having
pipes that were accurately tuned for each scale, and machinery so
adapted that all the scales could be controlled from one keyboard. B
flat and A sharp would no longer be represented by the same sound as
they are in the ordinary organ or piano, — which sound is in fact
neither B flat nor A sharp, but a compromise between the two, — but
each should have its true sound, and so on. Many thoroughly practical
and scientific musicians spoke warmly in favor of the new instrument,
but after a while the interest died out, and nothing practical came of
it. Whether this was because the instrument was too elaborate and
complicated for general use, or because no one took up the enterprise
in a business way and applied to its furtherance the necessary capital
and energy to insure success, I do not know. Perhaps no one does.
Probably Poole himself lost his interest in it as soon as he had
accomplished what he undertook.
It was about this time that I met him, one day, in the railroad
station at New Haven. While we stood talking together, a
small bell, perhaps a porter's call or something of the sort, rang out
near us rather sharply, hut not, to my ear, disagreeably so.
Poole jumped as though he had been shot, put both hands to his ears,
and looked wistfully at me, as much as to say, Let me know when it
stops. I can't take my hands down until I am sure. Then, gradually
recovering his equanimity, he said, "Ah! we'll soon put an end to all
that sort of thing. No use going through life in agony, when
everything can just as well be made pleasant."
"No," said I; "but how do you propose to do it?"
"Simply have all our sounds musical," said he; "easiest thing in the
world. That bell, now, might be a source of absolute pleasure instead
of throwing people into fits with its horrid din." And he proceeded to
give his theory of common concordant sounds which should produce this
elysium; but I have forgotten the details.
After this I lost sight of Poole for a good many years. I heard,
however, that he was in the city of Mexico, that he had acted as
professor (I think of modern languages) in a college there, and that
he was pleased with the country. One day, later on, I met him at the
Athenaeum Library in Boston, and had a talk with him, interesting,
intense, and iconoclastic as usual, about Mexico. During the
conversation he took from his pocket a handful of brilliant gems,
which he was apparently carrying loose with his knife, small change,
and other articles. I remember among them some very large and
beautiful rubies and emeralds, evidently of great value. Poole
immediately went off into a dissertation on gems. Each kind had its
history, and each individual stone its biography. He made it all very
interesting. I referred to his old interest in music. "Oh," he said,
with a faraway, dreamy look, " I had forgotten about that; so I had.
How long ago it seems That was the last time I saw him. A few years
ago, a friend of mine was about visiting Mexico, and upon his asking
me if I knew any one there, I gave him a letter to Poole, knowing no
special address, nor even if he were still there. My friend told me
afterwards that he found him without difficulty. He was living by
himself with a housekeeper and servant (he never married) in a small
house with a considerable yard, surrounded by a high wall, and guarded
by a number of dogs. At first there appeared to be some doubt about
the visitor being allowed to enter, but he was finally admitted. The
style of living, although perhaps not uncomfortable, seemed, to an
American eye, very careless and helter-skelter. My letter was
presented, but Poole was apparently not quite sure that he had ever
heard of me. He said, however, that he had known and forgotten so many
people that one more or less made no difference, and he began talking
immediately on Mexican affairs, showing munch more interest in them
than in anything that was happening at his old home.
This was the last, I think, that I heard of him, until I saw the
notice of his death but he was so full of resource and genius and a
certain kind of energy that one cannot help wishing to know more of a
life that must have been, to say the least, very picturesque.

🔗monz <monz@tonalsoft.com>

11/18/2005 4:12:53 PM

--- In tuning@yahoogroups.com, "threesixesinarow" <CACCOLA@N...> wrote:

> Contributors Club. The Atlantic Monthly Vol. LXVII,
> January 1891. p136
>
> One of the Lost Geniuses
>
> The telegraph announces the death in the city of Mexico,
> October 21st, of Henry Ward Poole,
>
> <snip>
> ... in 1850, Poole produced his Enharmonic Organ, which
> for a time attracted much attention in musical circles.
> His own account of it appeared in Silliman's Journal of
> Science ; and there were several articles in other
> magazines, and numerous notices in the papers of the
> time. As nearly as I can recollect, this invention was
> an attempt to give every scale perfectly, by having
> pipes that were accurately tuned for each scale, and
> machinery so adapted that all the scales could be
> controlled from one keyboard. B flat and A sharp would
> no longer be represented by the same sound as they
> are in the ordinary organ or piano, — which sound is
> in fact neither B flat nor A sharp, but a compromise
> between the two, — but each should have its true sound,
> and so on.

http://tonalsoft.com/monzo/poole/poole.htm

-monz
http://tonalsoft.com
Tonescape microtonal music software

🔗threesixesinarow <CACCOLA@NET1PLUS.COM>

11/18/2005 5:45:54 PM

http://sonic-arts.org:80/monzo/poole/poole.htm

The patent drawings are illustrative, accessible and public domain if
you need a picture - the labels on keys are more legible than in a
line drawing I made from it, and there's even a three rank pedal board
shown with straight keys like Bosanquet's.

> Notice that there are many schismatic equivalents. These are notes
> that are very close together in pitch, which I would call
> "xenharmonic bridges". Therefore, if Poole was willing to accept the
> "imperceptibility" of these equivalents, he could have reduced the
> size of the keyboard a great deal.

For the Indiana Place Chapel organ he wrote octaves were divisible
into fifty-three commas, but 17 years later, "In practical
construction... twenty-two of these [100] pipes may be dispensed with
in an organ, as the notes coincide so closely that there need not be a
difference of one-hundredth of a comma, which is well within the
limits of 'sympathy', and draws into perfect tune, were it five times
as great."

US 6,565 Alley & Poole. Organ action 03.07.1849
US 73,753. H. W. Poole. Improved Enharmonic key-board for Organs, &c.
28.01.1868
Poole, H. W. On Perfect Intonation and the Euharmonic Organ. New
Englander and Yale review. May 1850
Eliot, Samuel A. The Euharmonic Organ. The Living Age. September 7,
1850
Poole, H. W. On Perfect Harmony in Music. The Americal Journal of
Science and Arts. July, 1867
also http://www.esm.rochester.edu/sibley/specialc/findaids/display.
php?id=44

Clark