Schlick (H.Vogel)? (was alternate temperament formula?)

dividing each question with its own subject.

does anybody know this one? what kinda comma or ratio does it use?

Schlick (H.Vogel) : cents
0, -14.5, -5.5, -5.5, -11, 3, -16, -2.5, -12.5, -8, 1, -13.5

katsura

>Schlick (H.Vogel) : cents
> 0, -14.5, -5.5, -5.5, -11, 3, -16, -2.5, -12.5, -8, 1, -13.5

This looks very much like a reconstructed Schnitger temperament.
norden.scl in the scale archive:

Reconstructed Schnitger temperament, organ in Norden. Ortgies, 2002
85.5330 194.5260 32/27 389.0520 502.7370 583.5780 697.2630 787.4880
891.7890 1000.7820 4096/2187 2/1

Manuel

> >Schlick (H.Vogel) : cents
> >  0, -14.5, -5.5, -5.5, -11, 3, -16, -2.5, -12.5, -8, 1, -13.5
>
> This looks very much like a reconstructed Schnitger temperament.
> norden.scl in the scale archive:
>
> Reconstructed Schnitger temperament, organ in Norden. Ortgies, 2002
> 85.5330 194.5260 32/27 389.0520 502.7370 583.5780 697.2630 787.4880
> 891.7890 1000.7820 4096/2187 2/1

looks like it. does the name "Schlick (H.Vogel)" make sense?

0, -14.467, -5.474, -5.865, -10.948, 2.737, -16.422, -2.737, -12.512,
-8.211, 0.782, -13.685

and who created norden.scl? what's the source?

i'm looking for the original formula, not the results in cents (or
ratios) in .scl.

katsura

--- In tuning@yahoogroups.com, Hidetomo Katsura <katsura@m...> wrote:
> > >Schlick (H.Vogel) : cents
> > >  0, -14.5, -5.5, -5.5, -11, 3, -16, -2.5, -12.5, -8, 1, -13.5
> >
> > This looks very much like a reconstructed Schnitger temperament.
> > norden.scl in the scale archive:
> >
> > Reconstructed Schnitger temperament, organ in Norden. Ortgies,
2002
> > 85.5330 194.5260 32/27 389.0520 502.7370 583.5780 697.2630
787.4880
> > 891.7890 1000.7820 4096/2187 2/1
>
> looks like it. does the name "Schlick (H.Vogel)" make sense?
>
> 0, -14.467, -5.474, -5.865, -10.948, 2.737, -16.422, -2.737, -
12.512,
> -8.211, 0.782, -13.685
>
> and who created norden.scl? what's the source?

Again, see above -- the source is Ibo Ortgies.

> > and who created norden.scl? what's the source?
>
> Again, see above -- the source is Ibo Ortgies.

i'm looking for the commas and ratios used to calculate these results in the .scl files.

"the source is Ibo Ortgies" does not contain any information regarding the commas or ratios.

katsura

> >  >Schlick (H.Vogel) : cents
> >  >  0, -14.5, -5.5, -5.5, -11, 3, -16, -2.5, -12.5, -8, 1, -13.5
> >
> >  Reconstructed Schnitger temperament, organ in Norden. Ortgies, 2002
> >  85.5330 194.5260 32/27 389.0520 502.7370 583.5780 697.2630 787.4880
> >  891.7890 1000.7820 4096/2187 2/1
>
> 0, -14.467, -5.474, -5.865, -10.948, 2.737, -16.422, -2.737, -12.512,
> -8.211, 0.782, -13.685

now i calculated the commas from the accurate cents in .scl that Manuel
provided.

C -1/5P G -1/5P D -1/5P A -1/5P E -1/5P B -1/5P F# 0 C# 0 G# 1/5P Eb
1/5P Bb 0 F -1/5P

does this look familiar to anyone? i need the appropriate (and somewhat
short) name for this temperament. does "Schlick (H. Vogel)" make sense?

katsura