Question on Haresh's posts

Seth Austen wrote,

>many thanks for your wonderful and informative posts on
>various aspects of sruti

I've seen very little from Haresh on this subject and wondering if whatever
caused me not to recieve Robert's Solar System post and Joseph's reply is
acting up again. Indeed, Haresh seemed to be using new concepts which I
hadn't seen him introduce or explain. Could someone give a list of the post
involved, so I could be sure I haven't missed anything?

Dave provided me with a list of Haresh's posts. It does seem that, for
example, the concepts of "vadi" and "samvadi", and the idea that in Raga
Todi these might be A and Db, were introduced abruptly and with no previous
explanation of the definition of these concepts or any historical
discussions pertaining to them that we ought to be aware of . . . would it
be asking too much, Haresh, if I were to suggest that you present this
information a little more "gently", so that we may be gradually introduced
to new concepts, and may have a chance to ask questions, before you move on
to discuss more "advanced" matters such as this?

--- In tuning@y..., "Paul H. Erlich" <PERLICH@A...> wrote:
> Dave provided me with a list of Haresh's posts. It does seem that,
for
> example, the concepts of "vadi" and "samvadi", and the idea that in
Raga
> Todi these might be A and Db, were introduced abruptly and with no
previous
> explanation of the definition of these concepts or any historical
> discussions pertaining to them that we ought to be aware of . . .
would it
> be asking too much, Haresh, if I were to suggest that you present
this
> information a little more "gently", so that we may be gradually
introduced
> to new concepts, and may have a chance to ask questions, before you
move on
> to discuss more "advanced" matters such as this?

Definitely yes, Paul -- I can try.
Regards,
Haresh.

Note: When you mentioned the raga Todi above, I am sure you meant
Marwa. I will also check my posting to make sure I did not mention
the wrong raga.

Haresh wrote,

>When you mentioned the raga Todi above, I am sure you meant
>Marwa.

Yes, I did. Thanks for the correction.