back to list

Question for Monz on Marchetto

🔗Paul H. Erlich <PERLICH@ACADIAN-ASSET.COM>

1/27/2001 2:29:32 AM

In http://www.ixpres.com/interval/monzo/marchet/marchet.htm Monz writes,

>Since the 7-limit ratios would have the same letter-names as the 1:1, with
no >accidental, and since the 3-limit system would have to be an enormous
46-tone >linear system, which doesn't seem very likely for Marchetto's time
and place, my >suggestion is that his monochord division here was an attempt
to accomodate the >5-limit intervals given above.

Hi Monz,

Can you explain why the 3-limit system would have to be a 46-tone linear
system?