RE: [tuning] Re: uncommon practices [non-Western progs]

Joseph wrote,

>Well, there's no "vi," but still...

With just I, IV, and V, there's no comma problem. You need the ii chord to
really make it happen.

--- In tuning@egroups.com, "Paul H. Erlich" <PERLICH@A...> wrote:

http://www.egroups.com/message/tuning/12165

> Joseph wrote,
>
> >Well, there's no "vi," but still...
>
> With just I, IV, and V, there's no comma problem. You need the ii
chord to
> really make it happen.

Hi Paul!

But, then what was THIS all about??

F 4/3 -9.1¢ ---F 4:7 over G
E 5/4 | E 5/4
| D 2:3 over G
C 1/1 ---C 1/1 -9.1¢ C 1/1
[=2:3 over F] B 4:5 over G |
A 4:5 over F |
G 3/2 G 3/2 +9.1¢ ---G 3/2

OH! I guess I should have said V-7!!
_____________ ____ ___ __ __
Joseph Pehrson