back to list

Try tuning the beats out of a G13#11!

🔗D.Stearns <STEARNS@CAPECOD.NET>

8/23/2000 10:46:20 PM

Paul H. Erlich wrote,

> I notice you didn't include the 9th in yours (we should ask Dan if
he meant for there to be a 9th in the chord

Actually I was just quoting the example Patrick Mullen had given in
one of his posts:

"I am a jazz player too, and there are many jazz chords that don't
work well in the just scale, 7-limit or not.
In fact, 12tET has spawned harmonic extensions that sound really cool
in 12tET, but not so good when tuned to just intervals. As if such a
thing could even be done with some chords. Try tuning the beats out of
a G13#11! But it sounds very nice in 12tET. So when I play jazz, I
play just intervals when I can, but don't worry about it much
otherwise."

Interesting enough, in the context of Patrick's comment, Joe seems to
have posted a truncated 4:5:6:7:9:11:13 (where tuning out the beats
might be the least of the problems!), or a 4:5:6:7 G7:

5/4
/|\
/ | \
/ 7/4 \
/,' `.\
1/1-------3/2

and a 7:9:11:13 Bbmaj7#5:

9/8---11/8
`. ,'|
7/4 |
`.|
13/8

Dan