All 3 Drei Equale in TRUE Just Intonation.

I've finished retuning all 3 Drei Equale to true Just Intonation.
Consider this your reference for how actual in tune music sounds ;)

No1 in JI:
/makemicromusic/files/Marcel/Drei_Equale_no1_JI_%2820110302_MdV%29.mid

No2 in JI:
/makemicromusic/files/Marcel/Drei_Equale_no2_JI_%2820110302_MdV%29.mid

No3 in JI:
/makemicromusic/files/Marcel/Drei_Equale_no3_JI_%2820110302_MdV%29.mid

For comparison here the 12TET versions and a "classic 5-limit rational intonation" version of No1:
/makemicromusic/files/Marcel/Drei_Equale_no1_12TET.mid
/makemicromusic/files/Marcel/Drei_Equale_no2_12TET.mid
/makemicromusic/files/Marcel/Drei_Equale_no3_12TET.mid
/makemicromusic/files/Marcel/Beethoven_Drei_Equale_No1_%28classic-5-limit-JI%29.mid

And here the beginning of Lassus's Ave Regina Caelorum in true Just Intonation (a much used "comma pump" example to demonstrate the errors of various kinds of bad rational intonation systems)

JI:
/makemicromusic/files/Marcel/Lassus_comma-pump_JI_%2820110302_MdV%29.mid

And here the 12TET for comparison:
/makemicromusic/files/Marcel/Lassus_comma-pump_12TET.mid

As you can hear in all these examples, true Just Intonation sounds perfectly natural and has no wolves, held note comma shifts or drifting.

-Marcel

Haha ok..
Here we go again :)

I had made a mistake with a schisma in my theory.
And as a result even some syntonic comma's in these rederings (as the schisma leads to a different syntonic comma at the tritone as the tritone is allways 45/32 or its inversion.

As it turns out, I got Drei Equale no1 and no2 correct already on 22 October 2010 when I posted it to my website (Michael commented on it that it sounded great and Chris rendered it with 2 different sounds).

Here is the correct Drei Equale no1:

/makemicromusic/files/Marcel/Beethoven_Drei_Equale_no1_%28MJI_2010-10-22%29.mid

As for no2, it differs only by a schisma on 3 notes (minor chords, virtually inaudible) with the version I uploaded yesterday.
I'll upload the corrected one later today however.

As for no3, it becomes significantly different in several places.
I'll upload it later today as well.

-Marcel

--- In MakeMicroMusic@yahoogroups.com, "Marcel" <m.develde@...> wrote:
>
> I've finished retuning all 3 Drei Equale to true Just Intonation.
> Consider this your reference for how actual in tune music sounds ;)
>
> No1 in JI:
> /makemicromusic/files/Marcel/Drei_Equale_no1_JI_%2820110302_MdV%29.mid
>
> No2 in JI:
> /makemicromusic/files/Marcel/Drei_Equale_no2_JI_%2820110302_MdV%29.mid
>
> No3 in JI:
> /makemicromusic/files/Marcel/Drei_Equale_no3_JI_%2820110302_MdV%29.mid
>
>
> For comparison here the 12TET versions and a "classic 5-limit rational intonation" version of No1:
> /makemicromusic/files/Marcel/Drei_Equale_no1_12TET.mid
> /makemicromusic/files/Marcel/Drei_Equale_no2_12TET.mid
> /makemicromusic/files/Marcel/Drei_Equale_no3_12TET.mid
> /makemicromusic/files/Marcel/Beethoven_Drei_Equale_No1_%28classic-5-limit-JI%29.mid
>
>
> And here the beginning of Lassus's Ave Regina Caelorum in true Just Intonation (a much used "comma pump" example to demonstrate the errors of various kinds of bad rational intonation systems)
>
> JI:
> /makemicromusic/files/Marcel/Lassus_comma-pump_JI_%2820110302_MdV%29.mid
>
> And here the 12TET for comparison:
> /makemicromusic/files/Marcel/Lassus_comma-pump_12TET.mid
>
>
> As you can hear in all these examples, true Just Intonation sounds perfectly natural and has no wolves, held note comma shifts or drifting.
>
>
> -Marcel
>

--- In MakeMicroMusic@yahoogroups.com, "Marcel" <m.develde@...> wrote:
>
> Haha ok..
> Here we go again :)

Spam. I mean, really, at this point, it is just spam any more. After 3 years, you can't even get three little pieces correct, and you can't put up even one page on a website that summarizes your "theory".

You've got nothing, and you continually bother us. Take your own advice and stop posting.

I had the correct version up on this site for over 4 months.
I just had the bad luck of finishing no3 and redoing 1 and 2 and making a post about it the very moment I saw things wrong.
The wrong version has been up for less than 24 hours (the right one for over 4 months).

-Marcel

--- In MakeMicroMusic@yahoogroups.com, "jonszanto" <jszanto@...> wrote:
>
> --- In MakeMicroMusic@yahoogroups.com, "Marcel" <m.develde@> wrote:
> >
> > Haha ok..
> > Here we go again :)
>
> Spam. I mean, really, at this point, it is just spam any more. After 3 years, you can't even get three little pieces correct, and you can't put up even one page on a website that summarizes your "theory".
>
> You've got nothing, and you continually bother us. Take your own advice and stop posting.
>