19EDO vs. 17EDO

/makemicromusic/files/djtrancendance/sadness%20of%20anger%2019%20vs%2017EDO.mp3

This time I took Cameron's advice and tried to not translate directly from 12TET, but instead find harmonies that focus on each tuning's particular strengths and character.  Hopefully it won't sound "horrible" this time around.  Again there's no specific order so which version do you like...the first or the second one?

    Note: I didn't bother including 22EDO as it lost by a huge margin in the first listening test....

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

On Fri, Feb 11, 2011 at 1:45 PM, Michael <djtrancendance@...> wrote:
>
> /makemicromusic/files/djtrancendance/sadness%20of%20anger%2019%20vs%2017EDO.mp3
>
> This time I took Cameron's advice and tried to not translate directly from 12TET, but instead find harmonies that focus on each tuning's particular strengths and character.  Hopefully it won't sound "horrible" this time around.  Again there's no specific order so which version do you like...the first or the second one?
>
>     Note: I didn't bother including 22EDO as it lost by a huge margin in the first listening test....

It is, again, obvious which one is which. I like the first one. That
isn't to say that I would like a piece like the Juggler if it were put
into 17-TET or something.

-MIke